THE SCOTTISH
CONSTRUCTION
FOR USE IN DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL
ARBITRATION
A small group of individuals
has worked with great enthusiasm over the past twenty four months to produce
the Scottish Construction Arbitration Code, which, I believe, will offer
parties in Scotland in dispute a fast, efficient and cost effective Arbitration
process as an alternative to Adjudication.
This work, coupled with an
excellent level of input from the leading construction litigation firms in
Scotland, has created the basis for parties to have their disputes resolved
expeditiously, but below the frantic activity level of the current Adjudication
process. After wide consultation, the proposals have been warmly received by
users and construction litigators alike.
I firmly believe this Code
offers a genuine way forward to resolve construction disputes in Scotland and I
commend its use.
Ian
Trushell FRICS FCIArb
Chairman
Chartered
Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch)
1
December 2005
|
|
|
|
page |
|
article |
1 |
COMMENCEMENT OF ARBITRATION |
1. |
|
|
2 |
NOTICES AND COMMUNICATIONS |
3. |
|
|
3 |
CONSTITUTION OF THE ARBITRAL
TRIBUNAL, NUMBER OF ARBITRATORS AND
PROCEDURE FOR APPOINTMENT |
4. |
|
|
4 |
QUALIFICATIONS OF ARBITRATORS |
5. |
|
|
5 |
CHALLENGE OF ARBITRATORS |
6. |
|
|
6 |
REPLACEMENT OF ARBITRATORS |
7. |
|
|
7 |
TRUNCATED TRIBUNAL |
7. |
|
|
8 |
FEES AND EXPENSES |
8. |
|
|
9 |
COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN PARTIES
AND ARBITRATORS |
9. |
|
|
10 |
EXCLUSION OF LIABILITY |
9. |
|
|
11 |
PRELIMINARY ISSUES |
9. |
|
|
12 |
SEAT OF ARBITRATION |
10. |
|
|
13 |
LANGUAGE OF ARBITRATION |
10. |
|
|
14 |
SUBSTANTIVE LAW APPLICABLE |
10. |
|
|
15 |
CONDUCT OF PROCEEDINGS GENERALLY |
11. |
|
|
16 |
ADDITIONAL POWERS OF ARBITRATORS |
12. |
|
|
17 |
EVIDENCE, HEARINGS AND PLEADINGS |
13. |
|
|
18 |
EVIDENCE OF WITNESSES |
14. |
|
|
19 |
EXPERTS |
15. |
|
|
20 |
INTERIM MEASURES |
15. |
|
|
21 |
CLOSURE OF PROCEEDINGS |
16. |
|
|
22 |
THE AWARD |
17. |
|
|
23 |
CORRECTION OF AWARDS AND
ADDITIONAL AWARDS |
18. |
|
|
24 |
EXPENSES |
18. |
|
|
25 |
SETTLEMENT |
19. |
1.1 The party commencing arbitration (the
Claimant) shall give to the other party (the Respondent) a Notice of
Arbitration.
1.2 Arbitral proceedings shall be
deemed to commence on the date on which the Notice of Arbitration is received
by the Respondent.
1.3 The Notice of Arbitration shall
include the following:
(a) The full names and addresses of
the parties (including telephone and facsimile numbers and e-mail addresses if
known).
(b) A reference to the arbitration
clause or the separate arbitration agreement that is involved.
(c) A full statement of the
Claimant’s claim, including the nature of the claim, a statement of the
relevant facts and of the applicable law on which the Claimant relies and a
statement of the relief or remedy sought including details of the sum or sums
claimed and how they are made up. The claim shall be accompanied by copies of,
or relevant extracts from, the contract and such other documents (including a
full copy of any expert report(s)) as the Claimant intends to rely upon and
shall detail the relevant parts of the contract, and the relevant parts of any
such other documents, as are particularly relied upon by the Claimant.
(d) [Not used.]
(e) A demand that the matter be
referred to arbitration.
(f) If the arbitration clause or
agreement calls for each party to appoint an Arbitrator, the name and address
(and telephone and facsimile numbers and e-mail address if known) of the
Arbitrator nominated by the Claimant. The Respondent shall thereafter, within
seven days after receipt of the Notice of Arbitration, intimate the name and
address (and telephone, facsimile number and email address if known) of the
Arbitrator nominated by the Respondent.
(g) If the arbitration clause or
agreement does not call for each party to appoint an Arbitrator, a proposal by
the Claimant of the name of an Arbitrator with his full name and address (and
his telephone and facsimile numbers and e-mail address if known). The
Respondent shall, within seven days after receipt of the Notice of Arbitration,
intimate whether or not he accepts the Arbitrator nominated by the Claimant
and, if he does not accept him, the name and address (and telephone, facsimile
number and email address if known) of the Arbitrator whom the Respondent
proposes.
1.3.1 Within twenty one days after
receipt of the Notice of Arbitration (and irrespective of whether or not an
Arbitrator has by then been appointed in accordance with Article 3) the
Respondent shall deliver to the Claimant a Notice of Defence. Failure to deliver a Notice of Defence shall
not delay the arbitration. If there is such a failure all claims set forth in
the Notice of Arbitration shall be deemed to be denied.
1.4 The Notice of Defence shall
include:-
(a) Any comment on article 1.3(a)
(b) or (e) that the Respondent considers appropriate.
(b) A full statement of the
Respondent’s defence, including a statement of the relevant facts and of the
applicable law (if any) on which the Respondent relies in its defence and a
statement of the relief requested. The defence shall be accompanied by copies
of, or relevant extracts from, the contract and such other documents (including
a full copy of any expert report(s)) as the Respondent intends to rely upon,
except where such copies or extracts have already been provided by the Claimant
under Article 1.3(c), in which event the Respondent shall state its position
regarding the terms of such copies or extracts.
1.5 [Not used.]
1.6 The Respondent may include in
the Notice of Defence any counterclaim within the scope of the arbitration
clause or agreement and such counterclaim shall become part of the arbitration.
If so, the counterclaim in the Notice of Defence shall include those matters in
Article 1.3. (b), (c) and (e).
1.7 If a counterclaim is asserted in
the Notice of Defence, within twenty one days after its receipt, the Claimant
shall deliver to the Respondent a reply to the counterclaim which shall include
the same matters as provided for in the Notice of Defence in Article 1.4 with
the addition of a statement of the remedy requested, instead of the relief
requested, if considered appropriate by the Respondent.
1.8 Failure by the Respondent to
include a counterclaim in the Notice of Defence shall not preclude the
Respondent from making a counterclaim, within the scope of the arbitration
clause or agreement, no later than seven days after the later of the Notice of
Defence or the appointment of the arbitral tribunal (in terms of Article 3) if,
on cause shown, the arbitral tribunal in its absolute discretion is prepared to
permit it, in which event it shall become part of the arbitration.
1.9 If any party has been served
with a Notice of Arbitration he may, at any time before the arbitral tribunal
has been appointed, give Notice of Arbitration in respect of any other disputes
which fall under the same arbitration agreement. All disputes identified in
such Notice of Arbitration shall be consolidated within the same arbitral
proceedings.
1.10 After an arbitral tribunal has
been appointed, either party may give a further Notice of Arbitration to the
other, and to the arbitral tribunal, referring any additional dispute which
falls under the same arbitration agreement to the arbitral tribunal proceedings
and, whether or not the other party consents to that other dispute being
referred to the proceedings, the arbitral tribunal may in its absolute
discretion order that the additional dispute should be referred to and
consolidated within those same proceedings or that it should not be so referred
and consolidated.
1.11 [Not used.]
1.12 Immediately following the appointment of
an arbitral tribunal (in terms of Article 3) the Claimant shall send to the
arbitral tribunal a copy of all Notices of Arbitration in the arbitration and a
copy of all replies to any counterclaims in any Notices of Defence in the
arbitration. The Respondent shall send
to the arbitral tribunal a copy of all Notices of Defence (including any
counterclaims contained therein) in the arbitration. At the same time each party shall send to the arbitral tribunal
copies of, or relevant extracts from, the contract and such other documents as
the party intends to rely upon (except in so far as such action is made
unnecessary for the Respondent by Article 1.4(b)).
Notices and Communications article 2
2.1 All notices or other communications
between the parties and the arbitral tribunal shall be in writing and may be
delivered by courier or by registered/recorded post, or transmitted by
facsimile, e-mail or any other means of telecommunication which provides a
record of its transmission.
2.2 A party’s last known residence
or place of business during the arbitration shall be a valid address for the
purposes of any notices or other communications in the absence of any
notification of a change of address by that party to the other party and to the
arbitral tribunal.
2.3 For the purpose of determining
the date of the commencement of a time limit, a notice or other communication
shall be treated as having been received on the day it is delivered, or in the
case of a telecommunication, transmitted in accordance with Article 2.1.
2.4 For the purpose of determining compliance with a time limit, a notice or other communication shall be treated as having been sent made or transmitted if it is dispatched in accordance with Article 2.1 and 2.2 prior to or on the date of expiration of the time limit.
2.5 All communications with, and
other documents sent to, the arbitral tribunal by one party shall at the same
time be communicated to the other party.
Constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal,
Number
of Arbitrators and Procedure for Appointment article 3
3.1 The expression “the arbitral tribunal” in this Code includes a sole Arbitrator or all Arbitrators where more than one. All references to an Arbitrator shall include the masculine and the feminine, and Arbitrator shall include Arbiter.
3.2 The parties are free to agree on
the number of Arbitrators. If they have not agreed, a single Arbitrator shall
be appointed.
3.3 If the parties have agreed that
there shall be more than one Arbitrator and the Claimant has nominated an
Arbitrator in accordance with Article 1.3(f) but the Respondent fails
within seven days after receipt of the
Notice of Arbitration to intimate the name and address of another Arbitrator in
accordance with Article 1.3(f), the parties shall be deemed to have agreed on a
single Arbitrator and the Arbitrator nominated by the Claimant shall be deemed
appointed as the sole Arbitrator upon the expiry of the foregoing seven day
period.
3.4 If the parties have agreed that
there shall be a single Arbitrator and the Claimant has proposed an Arbitrator
under Article 1.3(g), and the Respondent does not intimate non-acceptance of
that Arbitrator within seven days after receipt of the Notice of Arbitration,
then the Arbitrator proposed by the Claimant shall be deemed appointed as the
sole Arbitrator upon the expiry of the foregoing seven day period.
3.5 Where the parties have agreed a
single Arbitrator be appointed and the Claimant has failed to propose an
Arbitrator in accordance with Article 1.3(g) or each party has nominated an
Arbitrator, they shall endeavour to agree on the single Arbitrator within seven
days of intimation of the name of the Respondent’s proposed Arbitrator under
clause 1.3(g). If they do so agree then the Arbitrator shall be deemed
appointed on the date of such agreement being reached. If they cannot agree
within that period either party may apply to the Chairman of the Chartered
Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch) to appoint the Arbitrator within
seven days of the application and the Arbitrator shall be deemed appointed on
the date of his or her appointment by the relevant officer of the Chartered
Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch).
3.6 Where parties have agreed on an
arbitral tribunal of three and each has appointed an Arbitrator then unless the
parties have agreed on another method of appointment the party-appointed
Arbitrators shall endeavour within seven days of the appointment of the later
of the two party-appointed arbitrators to be appointed to agree upon a third
Arbitrator who shall be the chairman of the arbitral tribunal, or if the
parties have so agreed shall act as oversman. If agreement upon the identity of
a third Arbitrator is so reached then the arbitral tribunal shall be deemed
appointed on the date of such agreement being reached. If the party-appointed
Arbitrators do not reach agreement within that time either party may apply to
the Chairman of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch) to
appoint that third Arbitrator or oversman within seven days of the application
and the arbitral tribunal shall be deemed appointed on the date of the third
Arbitrator’s appointment by the relevant officer of the Chartered Institute of
Arbitrators (Scottish Branch).
3.7 Where application has been made
to the Chairman of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch) to
appoint an Arbitrator and the relevant officer of the Chartered Institute of
Arbitrators (Scottish Branch) refuses or fails to make an appointment within
seven days of the application, either party may apply to the Court of Session,
Scotland to appoint the Arbitrator. In
the event of appointment of the arbitral tribunal by the Court of Session it
shall be deemed appointed on the date of appointment by the Court of Session.
3.8 Where the Chairman of the
Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch) is unavailable or unable
to act, a Vice-Chairman or the Secretary may act in his place.
3.9 For the purposes of this Article
the parties prorogate the exclusive jurisdiction of the Court of Session,
Scotland.
Qualifications of Arbitrators article
4
4.1 Any natural person of whatever
nationality who is of full age and capacity may be an Arbitrator.
4.2 Each Arbitrator shall be and
remain at all times independent and impartial.
4.3 Before nominating or proposing
an Arbitrator the party seeking to nominate or propose that Arbitrator shall
ascertain that that person is willing and able to accept appointment.
4.4 On being approached to act as Arbitrator,
the prospective Arbitrator shall disclose in writing to the party or parties
making the approach any circumstances likely to give rise to justifiable doubts
as to the Arbitrator’s impartiality or independence or confirm in writing that
no such circumstances exist. If at any stage in the arbitration circumstances
arise that may give rise to such doubts, the Arbitrator shall promptly disclose
those circumstances to the parties. Such circumstances include but are not
limited to bias, interest in the result of the arbitration and past or present
relationships with a party.
4.5 By accepting appointment the
Arbitrator shall be deemed to have undertaken to make available sufficient time
to enable the arbitration to be conducted and completed expeditiously. Prior to accepting appointment the
Arbitrator shall confirm in writing to the parties (or, if applicable, to the
relevant officer of the relevant appointing body, in which event the arbitrator
shall immediately after appointment copy such written confirmation to the
parties) that he will make available sufficient time to conduct, and will
conduct, the arbitration so as to conclude the arbitration within the
timescales provided in Articles 15.6, 15.7, 15.8, 15.9, 22.5 and 23.
4.6 Where parties are of different
nationality a sole Arbitrator (or chairman or oversman) shall not have the same
nationality as any of the parties unless they agree otherwise in writing. The
nationality of a party shall be understood to include that of controlling
shareholders or interests. Citizens of the European Union shall be treated for
this purpose as nationals of the different Member States and shall not be
treated as having the same nationality.
4.7 Article 4.6 shall not apply in
the case of an Arbitrator appointed as sole Arbitrator under Article 3.3.
4.8 By accepting appointment the
Arbitrator shall be deemed to be bound by this Code.
Challenge of Arbitrators article 5
5.1 A party may challenge an
Arbitrator if circumstances exist or arise giving rise to justifiable doubts as
to the Arbitrator’s impartiality or independence.
5.2 Such challenge may only be made
within fifteen days after the party challenging became aware of the
circumstances it considers give rise to justifiable doubt as to an Arbitrator’s
impartiality or independence.
5.3 The challenge shall be in
writing and shall be delivered to the other party and to the arbitral tribunal.
5.4 The other party may agree to the
challenge (in which case the Arbitrator shall withdraw from the arbitration) or
the challenged Arbitrator may decide to withdraw. In neither case does the
withdrawal imply acceptance by the Arbitrator of the validity of the grounds
stated for the challenge.
5.5 If the challenged Arbitrator
does not withdraw, the arbitral tribunal shall in the first instance decide
upon the challenge. In the event that it rejects the challenge the party making
the challenge shall have the right to apply to a tribunal of three persons to
be selected (subject always to the provisions of Article 3.8) by the Chairman
of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Scottish Branch) to decide the
challenge, and the decision of that tribunal shall be final.
5.6 If the challenge is upheld by
either the arbitral tribunal or the tribunal referred to in Article 5.5 the
challenged Arbitrator shall be deemed to have resigned upon the date of the
decision upholding the challenge.
5.7 Pending the decision of such a
tribunal the arbitral tribunal may in its discretion continue with the
arbitration.
Replacement of Arbitrators article 6
6.1 An Arbitrator shall not be entitled to resign or withdraw (except under Article 5) without the consent in writing of the parties, except upon the provision of a certificate from a registered doctor justifying resignation upon grounds of health.
6.2 When an Arbitrator has died,
withdrawn, resigned or been removed from office the position left vacant shall
be filled, unless the parties otherwise agree, by appointment by the Chairman
of the body designated in Article 3.5.
6.3 When a replacement Arbitrator is
appointed in the course of an arbitration, it shall be for the arbitral
tribunal to determine in its discretion whether any hearings held previously
shall be repeated.
6.4 If in the view of a party an
Arbitrator becomes incapacitated or unable to perform the duties of his office
the procedure in respect of Challenge of Arbitrators set out in Article 5 shall
apply.
6.5 Pending replacement of an
Arbitrator, the arbitral proceedings shall be suspended unless otherwise agreed
by the parties. Any period of
suspension shall be added to the period within which a final award must be
issued in terms of Articles 15.6 and 15.7.
If a period of suspension only commences after an extension has been
agreed under Article 15.8, or has arisen by operation of Article 15.9, the
period of suspension shall be added to the date agreed in terms of Article
15.8, or which applies by operation of Article 15.9.
Truncated Tribunal article 7
7.1 If an Arbitrator in a three person tribunal, although duly notified fails without good cause to participate in the work of the tribunal, the two other Arbitrators shall have the power in their sole discretion to continue the arbitration and to make any award, order or other decision despite the failure of the third Arbitrator to participate. In making this decision the two other Arbitrators shall have regard to all matters they consider appropriate in the circumstances of the case. The two Arbitrators shall notify the parties and the third Arbitrator that the arbitral tribunal has become a tribunal of two and that the arbitration shall continue to its conclusion.
7.2 If the two other Arbitrators
determine that the arbitration should not proceed without the participation of
a third Arbitrator, they shall declare in writing that the office of the third
Arbitrator has been vacated, and the procedure for replacing that Arbitrator
shall be carried through as if he had resigned in accordance with Article 6.2.
7.3 Upon the appointment of a
replacement Arbitrator in the circumstances of Article 7.2 the provision of
Article 6.3 shall apply in relation to the repetition of previous proceedings.
Fees and Expenses article 8
8.1 Each Arbitrator shall be
compensated on a reasonable basis determined at the time of appointment for
serving as an Arbitrator, and shall be reimbursed for his time, travelling and
other expenses incurred in the course of the arbitration.
8.2 Provided there is agreement in
writing in advance by the parties the Arbitrator’s fees may include a charge
for time reserved but not used as a result of late postponement or
cancellation.
8.3 In the event of failure to agree
at the time of appointment, or subsequently, on an arbitrator’s fees, they
shall be fixed upon the application of a party or the Arbitrator by the Auditor
of the Court of Session, Scotland.
8.4 Where the arbitral tribunal has
appointed a legal adviser, the fees and expenses of the legal adviser, if not
agreed, shall be fixed by the Auditor of the Court of Session upon the
application of a party or the arbitral tribunal.
8.5 Where the Auditor of the Court of
Session is to fix fees and/or expenses under Articles 8.3 and/or 8.4 he shall
do so in accordance with any basis of charge agreed between the Arbitrator and
the parties.
Communications between Parties
and Arbitrators article 9
9.1 Except as otherwise provided in these Articles or permitted by the arbitral tribunal no party or anyone acting on its behalf shall have any ex parte communications with any Arbitrator with regard to any matter of substance relating